Get a Free Insurance Quote

Family Owned with Family Values

Since 1972, our family-owned insurance company has been serving families through insurance for people living and working in Pike County, Pennsylvania and Orange County, New York. Our insured’s have relied on Yetter Insurance Agency and our services to protect themselves, their families, their businesses, and their assets for more than four decades.

As a client of Yetter Insurance Agency, we take the time to know you on a personal level. By understanding your needs, your wants, and your future goals, we can provide you with competitive quotes on multiple insurance options from a range of top insurers. We continue to work with you to evaluate your current insurance needs, making sure you get the right coverage and best value.

Our solid principles and our personalized service give you the peace of mind you need and deserve, especially in a time of need.

Our Products

News & Tips

What is life insurance?

February 8, 2023|

by Sherelyn J Schoch, President Yetter Insurance Agency, Inc. You hear me talk about life insurance and post about life insurance many times.  The truth is that no one wants to talk about life insurance or even think about life insurance.  The need for life insurance means that someone you [...]

Winter Holiday Pet Safety

December 8, 2022|

This article is provided for you by the American Veterinary Medical Association.  The original article can be found here. December abounds with holiday celebrations, and nothing can spoil good cheer like an emergency trip to the veterinary clinic. These tips can help keep your winter holiday season from becoming not-so-happy [...]

6 Things You Can Do Right Now to Protect Your Business Data

December 8, 2022|

This article was published by Sue Grabowski on September 27, 2022, on ErieSense blog.  The original article can be found here. As a business owner, you’ve probably heard a lot about cyber attacks when a large corporation makes headline news for a massive data breach. It’s no wonder business owners have [...]

We Offer

Our Community

We love the communities that we do business in and the people in them. We take the time to get to know our clients on a personal level because by understanding your needs, wants, and future goals, we can provide you with the most competitive and comprehensive quotes to help make sure you’re covered and reaching your goals.

Matamoras fire department
three people posing for photo at yetter insurance

What Our Clients Say

Yetter Insurance is dedicated to providing the best service and getting you the best deal. The Agency is professional and courteous and go out of their way to help every client. I would highly recommend them for all your Insurance needs!


Very happy with the service! I hit a deer on a Monday night and called. The first question asked was “are you alright?” They thought of me first! By Wednesday morning there was an adjuster at my house and within 3 days there was a check in my hand. Now… that is good service.


Just moved to the area–Jeff has done a great job of keeping us organized, explaining everything and just being a kind person in general. Thankful for this team!


Go to Top