Matamoras fire department

Serving The Community for More than 50 Years

Since 1972, our family-owned insurance company has been providing insurance solutions to people living and working in Pike County, Pennsylvania and Orange County, New York. Our insured have relied on Yetter Insurance Agency and our services to protect themselves, their families, their businesses, and their assets for more than four decades.

As a client of Yetter Insurance Agency, we take the time to know you on a personal level. By understanding your needs, your wants, and your future goals, we can provide you with competitive quotes on multiple insurance options from a range of top insurers. We continue to work with you to evaluate your current insurance needs, making sure you get the right coverage and best value. Our solid principles and our personalized service give you the peace of mind you need and deserve, especially in a time of need.

Our team is comprised of area residents that truly care about our insured. These are the people that are on the front lines answering the phones, preparing quotes, and working hard to ensure each of our clients receive prompt, personalized service.

Give us a call today to receive a free, fast, and accurate quote on any of your insurance needs. 570.296.8329

SherieAgency Principal
Sherie is the insurance agency’s principal, as well as the front line for sales and service in both personal and commercial lines. Prior to joining the agency in 2004, she gained several years of experience in accounting and bookkeeping. Sherie is the daughter of Yetter Insurance Agency’s founder, Greg Yetter.
JeffVice President
Jeff joined the agency in 2002. He brings 22 years of sales and service experience to the firm. Jeff genuinely cares for people and his passion is helping clients find the best insurance coverage available at the most affordable insurance rates possible.
Patti joined the agency in 2008. She brings with her over 20 years of experience as a licensed agent in personal lines and is our personal lines guru. She loves to take about her NY Giants and her grandchildren.
Ethan joined our team in 2022. He brings enthusiasm and genuine concern for people to his position as a personal lines agent. He comes from a local family with ties to the area for several generations.

We Offer